Should I buy a Ferrari 360 or 430? I’d buy the 430


The Ferrari 360 Modena and its successor, the F430 were two Ferrari models that marked a ground-breaking new direction for the Italian sports car manufacturer, with marked improvements in the handling department, the quality, and durability of components, and let’s not forget the wave of fresh visual flavor that came just when Ferrari needed a makeover most, rejecting yet another evolution of the pop-up lighted wedges that plagued Ferrari’s image in the 1980s and 1990s.

The Ferrari 360 Modena and F430 reigned in a time when technological advancement hadn’t quite crept in to be as integral to the nature of a sports car as it is today; nowadays, an entry-level sportscar is considerably more advanced in electronic wizardry as a supercar of 20 years ago.

The advantage of owning a sportscar like the 360 Modena or F430 is the opportunity to revel in the delight of a 400-horsepower sports car that retains a respectable level of practicality and usability, a car with handsome looks that are a breath of fresh air in the current haze of Transformer-like sportscars and supercars.

The Ferrari 360 Modena

Ferrari-360

The Ferrari 360 Modena was a gorgeous 2-seater sportscar produced from 2000 to 2005. The Modena, named after the birthplace of Enzo Ferrari, improved on the acclaimed F355 platform with a sophisticated alloy chassis in place of the F355’s steel monocoque design, and a wide, curvaceous body that featured then-futuristic Perspex-covered headlights, gaping air vents on either side of the front bumper for cooling and a sleek fastback design reminiscent of the 575 Maranello, housing an angled rear windshield through which every inch and facet of the 3.6l V8 could be observed in all its mid-mounted glory.

Moving away from a steel monocoque chassis design with an all-new aluminum space-frame chassis that was designed in partnership with Alcoa, the Ferrari 360 was 40% stiffer than the F355, with an aerodynamically-superior profile that generated 4 times the level of downforce when compared with its flat-nosed predecessor. Not only did this mean the 360 was slightly longer and girthier than the F355 on the outside, but it also afforded the driver and passenger more space to inhabit the cabin.

One of the most loveable aspects of the Ferrari 360 is its superb exhaust note, crisp and flamboyant, howling all the way to its 8,700rpm redline is an orchestra of delightful sounds, all of which credit goes to its 90-degree flat-planed crank V8 and five-valve per cylinder head.

When the 360 gets its vocal cords warmed up it’s really something to behold, and the charming feature many remember the car for. With 395 horsepower and 275 lb/ft of torque on tap, 62mph can be reached in a measly 4.5 seconds from a standstill, with a claimed top speed of 175mph or 185mph, depending on who you ask.

Managing all that horsepower is a 6-speed gated manual transmission, available with the iconic gated pattern for the purists, or an F1-style automated manual paddle-shift gearbox for the modernists.

The arrival of the 360 Spider

As significant as the changes were with the release of the Ferrari 360 Modena, it wasn’t until Ferrari put the 360 Spider on sale two years later that consumer appeal for the 360 dramatically rose – quickly overtaking sales of the hardtop Modena.

Ferrari had always planned a roadster variant, hence why the 360 Spider is so stunning to admire, unlike other convertible sportscars that appear more of an afterthought. Key structural areas of the new aluminum chassis were reinforced using thicker sections to add structural strength and torsional rigidity in preparation for the eventual roof removal.

Despite the slightly increased weight, the performance of the Spider is almost identical to that of the hardtop Modena variant.

Pricing the 360

Prices of the 360 are slowly on the increase, but remain more affordable than its predecessor, the F355, and surprisingly its successor also, the F430. Prices start at $80k for clean examples with good mileage and full-service history. Ferrari 360 models with desirable color combinations or optional extras fitted can fetch prices closer to $110k.

The Birth of the F430

Ferrari-F430-parked

The Ferrari F430 succeeded the 360 Modena upon its release in 2005 and seemed to mark an increased focus by Ferrari on improving the F430’s worthiness as a real track day competitor, and it’s no surprise. Look at what Ferrari was doing in Formula 1 at the same time and you’ll quickly understand why the F430 was such a revolutionary sportscar upon release. If the 360 Modena was fast, the F430 was ludicrous.

Power in the F430 was (up from 395hp in the 360, to) 483hp, with torque also rising significantly to 343ft/lbs – all thanks to a new 4.3l V8 that was a joint collaborative effort between Ferrari and Maserati.

Now, at long last, the Dino-derived engines Ferrari had been toying with for the past 50 years had been relegated to the museum, and the result was phenomenal. 80% of the F430’s torque was made available under 3,500rpm, offering a more practical powerband that helped the car launch off the line to 60mph nearly half a second quicker than the 360, in just 4 seconds flat.

Visually, the F430 wasn’t such a big hit as its predecessor, perhaps too tame for some, yet sleeker, more functional body lines brought forward improved cooling and visibility from the cabin. Despite the radical redesign of the aluminum body, which sat over a chassis very similar to that of the 360, not succeeding in lowering the drag coefficient when compared to the 360, the F430 benefits from increased downforce, allowing the car to remain planted while cornering and traveling at high speeds.

With a lack of pesky timing belts to be replaced and the build quality of the engine and peripherals being of an exceptionally high standard anyway, the reliability of the F430 is one of its many accolades. Intake manifolds can be prone to cracking if they weren’t recalled, and clutches can be expensive to replace, as are carbon-ceramic brake discs if the car has them.

Pricing the F430

The F430 has been increasing in value for some time, and where many analog purists might be on the hunt for the F355, especially its special editions, the F430 seems to appeal to sportscar owners that enjoy dabbling in some track actions here and there.

This means that higher mileage examples can be found from as little as $120k, but if you’re in the market for a car with fewer owners, lower mileage, and the option of some extras fitted, the majority of respectable examples cars can be found in the $150k – $190k price range.

The Verdict

Now is a great to invest in an important piece of Ferrari history. The 360 Modena and F430 are 2 modern-classic sportscars that symbolize a time of enormous success and innovation for Ferrari, bringing the technology of their then-unbeatable F1 cars to their roadgoing lineup; just take a look at how many of today’s sports cars and supercars show hints of influence from the Ferrari 360 and Ferrari F430!

If you’re in the market for a Ferrari, take your time and only work with reputable vendors in your area. Make yourself available to get an up-close look at the cars to see which appeals to you most, both of these stunning Ferrari models are special in their own right and deserve enough time for their beauty to truly be understood and appreciated. Taking a test drive can often be the best way to aid a good decision, and bring a grin to your face!

You may also like:

Can you buy old F1 cars?

Is a Ferrari worth it?

Is Corvette worth it?

Is a Porsche worth it?

Is Lamborghini worth the Money?

Should I buy a Supercar?

Should I buy a classic Mustang?

Are F1 experiences worth it?

John Cunningham

John is a writer, classic car and whiskey lover, men's shopping enthusiast and self appointed DIY expert. His greatest passion is repairing in the workshop, making old classics look and run like new again!

Recent Posts